Read or Jump On
THE CARRYING OF THE KNIFE IN ITALY.
I have already dealt in one of my first articles with the Normative Discipline (Art.52) concerning self-defence
It is with great pleasure that I publish this further brief article clarifying the Basic Principles of Carrying a Knife in Italy.
A huge thank you to Master Clod who authorised me to publish this article by Roberto Fantasia, one of his best Teachers
Master Claudio Alberton and his UFS Team, thanks to their experience, are doing important work in Italy in disseminating and training on street fighting and self-defence.
As Master Fantasia rightly pointed out: it is fundamental to work in an ETHICAL way and not to stir up exalted people for a few more clicks!
Master Fantasia’s Post, which originated to give a briefing on the Italian Discipline, was later prompted to give a broader view of legislation at the EUROPEAN Level
Terminology


Given the specific subject matter, I think it is useful to state some terminology at the beginning:
The knife was created by man to cut materials with a blade attached to a handle.
It differs in this from bladed weapons designed to offend the human body, such as the dagger.
Daggers differ from knives in that they have two cutting edges and two blades.
A fundamental distinction is that between knives with a fixed blade and knives with a folding or folding blade or pocket knife:
- Fixed-blade knives are those in which the blade is rigidly fixed permanently to the handle.
- Folding-blade knives are those in which the blade is movable and hinged in the handle into which it can be clamped (hence the name “switchblade”).
Folding knives
Within the category of folding knives a distinction must be made:
- Extendable knives: folding knives in which the blade is longer than the handle
- Balisong or butterfly knives are knives typical of the Philippines in which the handle is divided into two halves within which the blade is placed as in a case.
- Snap-open knives are knives in which the blade is opened automatically with the press of a snap button.
- Sliding-blade knives are knives in which the blade is not hinged or fixed on the handle, but slides inside it and comes out by force of gravity and because it is projected forward by a spring, until it is locked in the open position.
Carrying a knife in ITALY
Can you walk around with a knife in your pocket in Italy?
From the type of lock?
From the model of the knife?
Short answer ABSOLUTELY NO.
The 4-finger story

Apart from the fact that it would be necessary to see whose 4 fingers a blade is measured with as not all human beings are the same size, in fact the old Art. 80 liberalised – any knife with a fixed or folding blade of less than 4 cm in length (scalpel sharpener)
That’s where the story of the famous 4 fingers comes from….
Article 80 was in fact repealed by the cassation in 1975 without giving any indication of the minimum parameter of harm in order to be able to consider an object (not just a knife, but any object with a point, for example) to be offensive.
Result: In Italy today, you cannot take any knife/tool outside your home without a justified reason.
Justified Motive
And in this regard I am going to quote a simple example by Maestro Augusto Falconi: Carrying a knife, and with all the caution, certainly not wearing it, is not justifiable. For example, if I should ever find chicory in a meadow, but if I am going scuba fishing, I have my wetsuit, my rifle and my equipment, in the bonnet, inside the sheath, I can carry the knife. I can always be reported, but nobody will ever convict you just for carrying in this case.

THE PENS
Slight entity
imprisonment from six months to two years and a fine from EUR 1,000 to EUR 10,000. In minor cases involving the carrying of offensive objects only, only a fine may be imposed. The penalty is increased if the offence occurs during or at sporting events.
It is prohibited to carry weapons in public gatherings even for licensed persons. The offender is liable to a term of imprisonment of between one and three years and a fine of between EUR 3,000 and EUR 20,000. The penalty is imprisonment from three to six years and a fine from EUR 5,000 to EUR 20,000 when the offence is committed by a person without a licence.
Major entities
Whoever, outside the cases provided for in the previous paragraph, brings to a public meeting an instrument included among those indicated in the first or second paragraph, shall be punished by arrest from six to eighteen months and a fine ranging from 2,000 euro to 20,000 euro.
The punishment provided for in the third paragraph shall be doubled when one of the circumstances provided for in Article 4, second paragraph, of Law no. 895 of 2 October 1967 occurs, unless the use constitutes a constituent element or specific aggravating circumstance for the offence committed. The confiscation of weapons and other offensive objects must be ordered upon conviction.
Article 19 and the first and second paragraphs of Article 42 of the Consolidated Law on Public Security No. 773 of 18 June 1931, as amended, are repealed.
The poles of flags, placards and banners used in public demonstrations and processions, as well as other symbolic objects used in the same circumstances, are not considered weapons for the purposes of the criminal provisions of this article, unless they are used as blunt objects.
Citizens, and in particular hunters, must not carry any offensive instruments because they could be criminally convicted.
From the point of view of case law, in the case of violation of Article 4 of Law 110/75 with the attenuating circumstance of minor importance and conviction to a fine, the first applications of Article 131 bis of the Criminal Code for the fact
Port of the Knife in EU countries:
An overview of legislation
But in the rest of Europe how does the law behave toward a knife man?
Knife regulations in European countries are generally consistent.
There is generally a maximum limit to the blade length for carrying knives, and a valid justification or legitimate purpose is required for regular carriage.
In almost all countries there are lists of prohibited items that include various cutting tools.
Let’s have a look at the situation in different european countrieshere


Germany
In Germany it is possible to carry even without justification (not everywhere) a fixed-blade knife up to 12 cm long.
German law, however, has a long list of prohibited knives and restricted-use items that you are not allowed to have with you normally including slashing and pointing weapons, ALL OPENING KNIVES WITH ONE HAND AND LOCKED BLADE (slipjoint only to be clear), butterfly knives (balisong).
In addition, in order to safeguard public safety and maintain order, individual states have the authority to enact local regulations restricting the carrying of weapons and other dangerous items.
To summarize: there are knives allowed, knives allowed with justifiable reason, and “no weapons” zones ( rallies, concerts, sporting events etc etc).
Austria
In Austria the law is simple, animated sticks and knives disguised as other objects ( buckles, credit cards, keys, brushes etc etc) are prohibited. End.
Belgium
Throwing knives, shuriken , and knives disguised as knives are prohibited.
Knives of any size are prohibited in your vehicle unless you have a valid reason for doing so.
France
there are two limits on the carrying of blades: they cannot be more than 15 cm long and thicker than 4 mm.
Knives with blade locks, knuckleballs, tomahawks, shuriken, and cutting weapons are not allowed to be carried or carried in the trunk.
Spagna
camouflaged knives, automatic or semiautomatic rapid opening knives, and in general all lockable knives above 11 cm are prohibited. Butterfly knives and pusher daggers and daggers prohibited.
Justifiable reason is always needed however.
Portugal
Blade less than 10cm otherwise justifiable reason is needed.
Banned automatic and semiautomatic knives, throwing knives, butterfly knives, pusher daggers and fixed knives with guards ( ka bar type) forbidden to hide and carry concealed and must obviously be carried closed ( interesting law).
Czech Republic
drum roll: NO LAWS REGARDING KNIVES EXIST- common sense applies! ( all on vacation in the Czech republic )
Croatia
Croatian law considers daggers, swords, sabers, automatic and semiautomatic knives, shuriken, throwing objects regardless of length or that they are


Greece
Large knives are prohibited in Greece! What exactly this means one must ask whoever devised this law, when in doubt it is the arresting officer who decides concretely.
In general objects of a size consistent with the task at hand are tolerated( cutting an apple, killing a bison, eliminating a sentry, etc. etc.).
Prohibited however are butterfly knives, automatics, daggers, push dagger.
Ireland
No peace of mind here-it is forbidden to carry anything capable of cutting. In a limited framework however carrying may be allowed with must be justified reason.
Possession is not prohibited but only the carrying and importation of certain types of l’amore.
Norway
Norway has an absolute ban on carrying knife in the city! Here the knife must be outside the immediate availability of the person carrying it. Outside the city the principle of legitimate interest applies i.e.-trekking- fishing- hunting- trips to the woods-. Daggers, butterfly knives and assisted opening pocket knives are prohibited.
Denmark
Banned knives that can be opened with one hand, automatics, pusher daggers, fixed blade knives with extractions, no neck knives or boot knives. Fixed-blade knives no longer than 12 cm and 7 cm slipjoint allowed. Carrying a victorinox is permitted.
Finland
No butterfly or snap knives or bayonets, otherwise ABSOLUTE FREEDOM.
Sweden
Ireland type: no knives in public place in woods instead just ” use common sense
Poland
Not expressly forbidden to carry blades as long as they are of “normal size ” banned throwing knives, camouflaged knives, etc. etc.
Switzerland
Here a distinction is made between weapons and offensive objects. Weapons include daggers, pusher daggers, throwing blades, butterfly knives, all knives with easy opening spring mechanisms. Carrying and carrying victorinox is explicitly allowed.
England
until January 31, 2020, the United Kingdom was part of the European Union (EU) and still remains a strong tourist destination so let’s also see the situation here:
Permitted to carry without justified reason a lockable knife with a blade no longer than 3 inches ,( 7.6 cm) and without a blade lock (slipjoint). Larger knives must have justifiable reason. No knives allowed in gathering places such as pubs, sporting events, shopping malls, events or other public places. Assisted opening or flipper knives may be held but not carried. All other knives are prohibited.

The knife as a method of self-defence
I have not had time to write my conclusions to the article that Master Roberto Fantasia comes out with another post that fits in perfectly with my thinking
I am therefore going to add a new chapter to answer a frequently asked question: Does it make sense to propose studying the knife as a method of self-defence?
No, or at least not in this century and for several reasons.


1) Learning to defend oneself is not for everyone and implies considerable physical and psychological preparation, all the more so when we are talking about blades and the street.
On the street, even defending oneself with bare hands is difficult because we are not in a controlled environment, there are no rules and there is no referee.
We can be attacked by surprise, from behind, by several people, and with weapons… so coming out well is really unlikely.
Practising a ‘real’ combat sport certainly makes a difference because those who practise boxing, muay thai, mma, wrestling, judo, sambo, etc. etc. are used to and trained for confrontation, they know what it means to take blows, to respond to attacks, to manage their breath, their sense of distance, etc. etc. All these things cannot be replicated by the same person. All things that cannot be replicated in a self-defence course of one or two evenings a week.
In short, to learn how to defend yourself you have to know how to fight. (this reminds me of what we had already written several times in this blog, such as here or in one of my first articles ‘training Vs reality‘)
2) In our country, it is forbidden to carry any kind of knife (see above).
Carrying a knife ‘for self-defence’ in your pocket IS NOT CONSIDERED JUSTIFYING.
On the contrary, if I cause injury to my attacker I will almost certainly get into trouble in court because the weapon was mine and I had carried it in my pocket illegally.
3) Would you seriously use a knife against an armed attacker?
Apart from the bluster like ‘if I get angry no one will stop me’ ‘I can’t do sport because if I feel bad I get bad’ etc etc, the person attacking you is a CRIMINAL and is used to behaving like that, he lives in violence, you don’t (hopefully).
4) If someone wants to give you a knife, he gives it to you and you keep it.
No one who seriously wants to hurt you shows you the knife, he usually pulls it out just before hitting you and keeps it well hidden.
If he pulls it out and shows it to you and you do the same you are engaging in a rustic duel but they have not been used for a century and are illegal in Italy too
5) Is training with a knife useful? Sure like training in fencing, kali, kendo.
Sparring with weapons improves eye contact, timing and above all a sense of distance BUT IT MUST BE COMBINED WITH ATHLETIC PREPARATION AND COMBAT SPORTS or the psychological aspect of the clash and athletic preparation will be missing.
There are schools, see the Dog Brothers’ kali tudo, that have been practising full-contact combat (with protections) for many years. Man (and experience) always makes a difference.
So how do you defend yourself against an attacker armed with a knife?
As Sifu Marcelo says…RUN AWAY
Conclusion
BETTER TO GAIN CLARITY AND STAY AWAY FROM FALSE GURUS. (quoting Master Clod)
In my small experience I have always been a sceptic when I see knife defence techniques.
I personally always find them very ineffective in the way they are taught in gyms and difficult, if not impossible, to apply.
I believe that anyone who attacks you with a knife, if he really intends to use it to injure and/or kill, does not show it to you and if he does, he is not an expert with the knife.
Furthermore, theoretically you should not have a knife in the street so why spend time teaching something that will most likely not be useful in the case of a street fight?
From my point of view I think it is useful to have a basic knowledge and therefore to know the angles of attack and the various risks and consequences of defending and using a knife.
Everything else I consider to be the specific subject of those who make defence a profession, such as the police and the military, or those who, out of pure passion, have the opportunity to study this interesting weapon.
After all, the study of bladed weapons (bladed weapons, edged weapons and blunt weapons), besides being very fascinating, is good training for the study of distances, movement and coordination.
Knives (all, any size) may only be carried for ‘justified reason’.
In all other cases you must be in a situation where it can be demonstrated that you have carried or are carrying the knife for a specific and legal purpose.
Carrying for self-defence is not permitted
Final premise:
We teachers have a duty not to incite violence. But at the same time to remember, how dangerous the knife is in experienced hands. But also in non-expert hands
I want to close with one last quote which, as per the premise, I obviously endorse
People who advertise knife-fighting methods as SELF-Defense should be banned from social media for manifest mental incapacity
(quoting R. Fantasia)


Your posts always speak to me on a personal level and I believe that is a testament to your authenticity and genuine nature
Thanks for your nice words
Just as an FYI on Danish law regarding knives.
It’s not permitted to carry a knife anywhere, unless it’s for a specific purpose, just like in norway.
If you want to carry a knife over 12 cm for specific purposes (self defense is not a legal purpose) or some specific types of knifes, then you need a knife permit.
The knife permit can be “circumvented” in specific cases, like with filé knifes when fishing (it’s still not really legal, but the police tends to “overlook” it).
Forgot to mention regarding the knife permit.
The “not really legal” is due to the finer print, where you have to go directly to and from the place where you need it and your home (which people rarely do).
The circumvention is when using knifes that has a specific purpose, but you can only use that knife for that pupose, so you can’t fx. take your filé knife into the forest if you plan to use it for fx. carving wood.
Hi Jan. Thanks for your add
dammit, I hit “post” by a mistake so my comment is only half true, and can’t edit it xD
A sharp EU knife guide that slices through the legal fog—Italy’s no-justification-no-carry rule (bye, self-defense excuses!) meets a patchwork of blade bans from auto-openers in Spain to city curbs in Norway. Vital for travelers: Match your tool to the task, or risk fines that cut deep. Stay legal, stay safe!